Best Bakeries in St. Thomas: The Ultimate Guide

Where to Find Fresh Bread, Croissants, Johnny Cakes, Rum Cake, Cinnamon Rolls, Local Pastries, and the Island's Best Bakeries in St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands

Introduction

Some of the best food you'll eat in St. Thomas won't come from a five-star restaurant—it'll come from a neighborhood bakery before 9:00 in the morning.

Whether you're craving a buttery croissant with freshly brewed coffee, a warm loaf of island bread, a traditional johnny cake, or an authentic Caribbean rum cake to bring home, St. Thomas has a bakery for every occasion. From long-standing local institutions to modern cafés and specialty cake shops, these bakeries offer much more than desserts.

This guide covers the best bakeries in St. Thomas, what each is known for, and where to find everything from breakfast pastries to celebration cakes.

At a Glance: Best Bakeries in St. Thomas

The island has only a handful of dedicated bakeries, but each has developed a loyal following for specialties ranging from fresh island bread and pastries to custom cakes and authentic Caribbean baked goods. (Tripadvisor)

1. MBW Cafe & Bakery — Best Overall

MBW Cafe & Bakery Web Address: St. Thomas, 1-6 Donoe Estate, Charlotte Amalie, St Thomas 00802, US Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-715-2767

More than just a bakery, MBW Cafe & Bakery is part of the nonprofit My Brother's Workshop, which provides education and job training for local youth. Every purchase helps support the program while treating visitors to outstanding baked goods. (St. Thomas Activities)

Don't Miss

• Fresh pastries

• Rum cake

• Breakfast sandwiches

• Homemade breads

Price: $$

Best For

• Breakfast

• Coffee

• Supporting local businesses

• Fresh pastries

2. Weekes & Weekes Bakery — Best Fresh Bread

Weekes & Weekes Bakery Address: 83R8+X3G St Thomas, Guttets Gade, Charlotte Amalie, St Thomas 00802, U.S. Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-776-0663

If you want to experience an authentic neighborhood bakery, Weekes & Weekes should be your first stop.

Locals have been picking up fresh bread, sweet buns, and island pastries here for years.

Try

• Fresh island bread

• Sweet rolls

• Coconut bread

• Traditional pastries

3. House of Pastries & Deli — Best Croissants

House of Pastries & Deli Web Address: 5507 Curacao Gade, Charlotte Amalie, Saint Thomas 00802, U.S. Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-776-5145

House of Pastries combines a traditional bakery with a breakfast deli.

Their flaky croissants and breakfast pastries make this one of the best early-morning stops in Charlotte Amalie.

Signature Items

• Butter croissants

• Danish pastries

• Breakfast sandwiches

• Cinnamon pastries

4. Daylight Bakery — Best Local Bakery

Daylight Bakery And Diamond Barrel Restaurant Web Address: 83RF+H6V St Thomas, Norre Gade, Charlotte Amalie, St Thomas 00802, U.S. Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-776-1414

If you want to eat where locals do, Daylight Bakery is an excellent choice.

This no-frills bakery specializes in Caribbean baked goods and hearty breakfast favorites served in a relaxed neighborhood setting. (Tripadvisor)

5. Jr's Cakes & Bakes — Best Johnny Cakes

Jr's Cakes & Bakes Address: St Thomas, Anna's Retreat, St Thomas 00801, U.S. Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-514-2462

One of the best places on the island to experience authentic local baking.

Don't Miss

• Johnny cakes

• Saltfish breakfast

• Coconut bread

• Island pastries

This is an excellent stop if you want a traditional Virgin Islands breakfast instead of a tourist café.

6. duAL chefs — Best Artisan Bakery

duAL chefs Web Address: St. Thomas, 2001 Bakery Square, Charlotte Amalie, St Thomas 00802, U.S. Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-203-1919

Hidden in Bakery Square, duAL chefs has quickly earned a reputation for chef-quality breads, pastries, and outstanding bagels.

It's one of those places visitors often wish they had discovered earlier in their trip.

7. Sweet Surrender VI — Best Birthday Cakes

Sweet Surrender VI Web Address: 1829 Kongens gade st. thomas VI, Charlotte Amalie 00802, 4714, U.S. Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-626-1310

Celebrating while visiting St. Thomas?

Sweet Surrender creates beautiful custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and desserts perfect for birthdays, anniversaries, and destination weddings.

8. Island Sweet Stuff — Best Wedding Cakes

Island Sweet Stuff Web Address: St. Thomas, 2004 Bakery Square Ste. 5C, Charlotte Amalie, St Thomas 00802, US Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-201-6436

Known throughout the island for elegant custom cakes, Island Sweet Stuff specializes in destination weddings and celebrations.

If you're planning an event in St. Thomas, this is one of the island's premier cake studios.

9. Josie's Special Event & Bakery — Best Rum Cake

Josie’s Special Event & Bakery Address: r, Charlotte Amalie West 14A Contant Charlotte Amalie, St Thomas 00802, U.S. Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-228-4423

Rum cake is one of the Caribbean's signature desserts.

Josie's has become a favorite for beautifully decorated cakes while also earning praise for its rich, flavorful rum cakes. (Tripadvisor)

10. Stir It Up Coffee Shop & Bakery — Best Coffee & Pastries

Stir It Up Coffee Shop & Bakery Web Address: 9100 Port of Sale Mall Ste. 2 St. Thomas US, 00802, U.S. Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-642-9972

Located near the Havensight cruise port, Stir It Up is the perfect stop before a day of sightseeing.

Fresh croissants, muffins, specialty lattes, and breakfast pastries make it one of the island's most convenient bakery cafés.

Where to Find the Best...

Fresh Bread

• Weekes & Weekes Bakery

• MBW Cafe & Bakery

• Daylight Bakery

Croissants

• House of Pastries & Deli

• Stir It Up Coffee Shop & Bakery

• duAL chefs

Cinnamon Rolls

• MBW Cafe & Bakery

• House of Pastries & Deli

• Daylight Bakery

Local Pastries

For authentic Virgin Islands baked goods, visit:

• Daylight Bakery

• Weekes & Weekes Bakery

• Jr's Cakes & Bakes

Johnny Cakes

The best places to find fresh johnny cakes include:

• Jr's Cakes & Bakes

• Daylight Bakery

Coconut Tarts

Look for traditional coconut tarts and island sweets at:

• Weekes & Weekes Bakery

• Daylight Bakery

Rum Cake

Don't leave St. Thomas without trying rum cake from:

• MBW Cafe & Bakery

• Josie's Special Event & Bakery

• Sweet Surrender VI

Birthday Cakes

For celebrations, consider:

• Sweet Surrender VI

• Island Sweet Stuff

• Josie's Special Event & Bakery

Best Coffee Pairings

Pair your pastry with excellent coffee at:

• Stir It Up Coffee Shop & Bakery

• Northside Grind

• Lattes in Paradise

• Island Grind Main Street

Best Morning Bakery Stops

Start your day at:

• MBW Cafe & Bakery

• House of Pastries & Deli

• Northside Grind

Bakeries Near the Cruise Port

If you're arriving at Havensight or Crown Bay:

• Stir It Up Coffee Shop & Bakery

• MBW Cafe & Bakery

• House of Pastries & Deli

Bakeries Near Red Hook

The Red Hook area has fewer dedicated bakeries, but these nearby cafés offer excellent pastries:

• Lattes in Paradise

• Picaso's Coffee Bar

Hidden Local Bakeries

For visitors looking to venture beyond the most popular tourist spots:

• duAL chefs

• Daylight Bakery

• Weekes & Weekes Bakery

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I find the best fresh bread in St. Thomas?

Weekes & Weekes Bakery is widely regarded as one of the island's best destinations for fresh island bread and traditional baked goods.

Who makes the best rum cake?

MBW Cafe & Bakery is especially well known for its rum cake, though Josie's Special Event & Bakery and Sweet Surrender VI are also excellent choices. (Tripadvisor)

Where should I stop before sightseeing?

Stir It Up Coffee Shop & Bakery and House of Pastries & Deli are both convenient options near downtown Charlotte Amalie and the cruise port.