Best Happy Hour in St. Thomas: The Ultimate Guide

Where to Find the Best Drink Specials, Sunset Cocktails, Beach Bars, Waterfront Happy Hours, and Local Favorites in St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands

One of the best ways to experience St. Thomas is slowing down with a cold drink as the afternoon fades into sunset. Whether you're fresh off a snorkeling trip, wrapping up a day of shopping in Charlotte Amalie, or returning from a Phoenix Island Charters excursion, happy hour is the perfect excuse to enjoy the island's laid-back atmosphere.

From waterfront cocktail lounges to lively tiki bars and beachside hangouts, St. Thomas has a happy hour for every type of traveler.

At a Glance: Best Happy Hour in St. Thomas

1. Duffy's Love Shack

Best Overall Happy Hour

If you ask locals or repeat visitors where to grab a drink in St. Thomas, Duffy's Love Shack is almost always part of the conversation.

Located in Red Hook, this legendary tiki bar is famous for colorful cocktails, energetic crowds, and one of the island's liveliest daily happy hours. It's especially popular before dinner or as the first stop of an evening out. Wanderlog

Don't Miss

• Painkillers

• Bushwackers

• Frozen cocktails

• Specialty tiki drinks

Best For

• Groups

• Nightlife

• First-time visitors

• Red Hook bar hopping

2. The Easterly

Best Sunset Happy Hour

Located overlooking Cowpet Bay near Red Hook, The Easterly pairs upscale cocktails with beautiful waterfront views.

Happy hour is available daily in the bar area and features discounted craft cocktails, mocktails, local beer, select wines, and creative small plates. Easterly Seafood

Best Time to Visit

Arrive about an hour before sunset for the best atmosphere.

3. Caribbean Fish Market

Best Upscale Happy Hour

If you're looking for a more refined experience, Caribbean Fish Market offers one of the island's best upscale happy hours.

Daily specials include cocktails, wine, beer, and discounted appetizers in the bar and courtyard areas. Caribbean Fish Market

Highlights

• Seafood appetizers

• Wine specials

• Premium cocktails

• Elegant waterfront setting

Perfect before a romantic dinner.

4. Sunset Grille

Best Scenic Happy Hour

As the name suggests, Sunset Grille shines during golden hour.

Its daily happy hour features drink specials alongside appetizers like coconut shrimp, wings, ahi tuna nachos, and barbecue ribs. Sunset Grille

5. The Shack at Hull Bay

Best Local Beach Bar

The Shack feels like classic island life.

Overlooking Hull Bay, it's known for fresh seafood, frozen drinks, live music, and a relaxed crowd of surfers, fishermen, and locals. The restaurant currently offers a daily "Heine-Time Happy Hour" from 3–5 PM featuring discounted Heinekens. The Shack

6. Tap & Still

Best Beer Happy Hour

If you're craving burgers, wings, and a great beer selection, Tap & Still is one of the island's favorite casual stops.

Its Red Hook location is especially popular after beach days and ferry trips to St. John. Wanderlog

7. Fish Bar

Best Seafood Happy Hour

Fish Bar in Hull Bay has earned a loyal following thanks to locally sourced seafood and fresh daily specials.

Happy hour is a great opportunity to sample several dishes while enjoying views of Hull Bay before the dinner rush. Coldwell Banker U.S. Virgin Islands

8. Rum Island Pub

Best Downtown Cocktails

Located near Charlotte Amalie's waterfront, Rum Island Pub is a convenient stop after sightseeing or shopping.

Its relaxed atmosphere and rum-focused menu make it a favorite for visitors looking to unwind before dinner. Wanderlog

9. Agave

Best Margaritas

If tequila is more your style than rum, Agave offers one of the island's strongest happy hours.

Daily specials include discounted margaritas, sangria, beer, shots, and Mexican-inspired appetizers from 3–6 PM. agavevi.com

10. Island Time Pub

Best Harbor Views

Located at American Yacht Harbor in Red Hook, Island Time Pub combines harbor views with casual food, cold drinks, and a relaxed outdoor setting.

It's a great place to watch boats come and go while enjoying pizza, seafood, and cocktails. Wanderlog

Best Happy Hours by Category

Best Beach Happy Hour

• The Shack

• Fish Bar

• Duffy's Love Shack

Best Waterfront Happy Hour

• Caribbean Fish Market

• The Easterly

• Island Time Pub

Best Sunset Drinks

• The Easterly

• Sunset Grille

• Caribbean Fish Market

Best Rum Cocktails

• Duffy's Love Shack

• Rum Island Pub

• The Shack

Best Margaritas

• Agave

Best Craft Cocktails

• The Easterly

• Caribbean Fish Market

• Sunset Grille

Best Local Atmosphere

• Fish Bar

• The Shack

• Rum Island Pub

Classic Virgin Islands Drinks to Try

No happy hour in St. Thomas is complete without sampling a few island favorites:

• Painkiller

• Bushwacker

• Rum Punch

• Frozen Mango Daiquiri

• Cruzan Rum Mojito

• Piña Colada

• Dark 'n Stormy

For a deeper dive into the island's signature spirit, check out our Complete Guide to Virgin Islands Rum.

Happy Hour Tips

• Many specials are available only at the bar.

• Arrive early if you want waterfront seating.

• Sunset reservations are rarely needed for happy hour, but popular venues fill up quickly.

• If you're heading out on a boat the next morning, enjoy responsibly and stay hydrated.

Perfect Happy Hour Itineraries

After a Charter

Spend the day exploring hidden beaches with Phoenix Island Charters before heading to The Easterly or Caribbean Fish Market for cocktails overlooking the water.

After Shopping

Explore Charlotte Amalie's historic streets before relaxing with a rum cocktail at Rum Island Pub.

After the Beach

Finish your day at Hull Bay with frozen drinks and fresh seafood at The Shack.

Frequently Asked Questions

What time is happy hour in St. Thomas?

Most restaurants begin happy hour between 3:00 PM and 5:00 PM, with many ending around 6:00 or 7:00 PM, though times vary by venue. The Shack

Where is the best happy hour in Red Hook?

Duffy's Love Shack, The Easterly, Tap & Still, and Island Time Pub are all excellent choices within a short walk of one another. Wanderlog

What's the most popular drink in St. Thomas?

The Painkiller is arguably the island's signature cocktail, followed closely by the Bushwacker and traditional Caribbean rum punch.