Best Ice Cream in St. Thomas: The Ultimate Guide

Where to Find the Best Ice Cream, Gelato, Milkshakes, Frozen Treats, and Sweet Desserts in St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands

Introduction

Nothing hits the spot after a day at Magens Bay, snorkeling at Coki Beach, or shopping in Charlotte Amalie quite like a cold scoop of ice cream.

While St. Thomas isn't overflowing with ice cream shops, the ones it does have are worth seeking out. From handcrafted gelato and fresh waffle cones to boozy milkshakes and tropical fruit flavors, you'll find plenty of ways to cool off while exploring the island.

Whether you're traveling with kids, looking for a romantic dessert after dinner, or simply craving something sweet before heading back to your resort, this guide covers the best ice cream shops in St. Thomas and what makes each one unique.

At a Glance: Best Ice Cream in St. Thomas

These shops consistently receive some of the highest praise from both locals and visitors for quality, flavor, and service. (Tripadvisor)

1. Scoops & Brew — Best Overall

Scoops & Brew Web Address: 7180 Crown Bay Marina Box 505-95, St Thomas 00802, U.S. Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-690-2739

If you're only stopping for ice cream once during your vacation, this is the place.

Located inside Crown Bay Marina, Scoops & Brew combines artisan gelato, sorbet, espresso drinks, smoothies, and breakfast favorites under one roof. It's equally popular with cruise passengers, boaters, and locals.

Don't Miss

• Homemade gelato

• Fresh waffle cones

• Tropical sorbets

• Affogato

• Espresso drinks

Price: $$

Best For

• Couples

• Families

• Cruise passengers

• Coffee lovers

Insider Tip

It's the perfect stop after returning from Water Island or before boarding a sailing excursion.

2. Udder Delights Ice Cream Parlor — Best Milkshakes

Udder Delights Ice Cream Parlor Address: St. Thomas, No. 3A Estate Lovenlund, 6200 Magen's Bay Rd, Charlotte Amalie, 00802, US Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-774-7256

Located on the road to Magens Bay, Udder Delights has become a tradition for many repeat visitors.

Their incredibly thick milkshakes are legendary, and adult visitors can even order rum-infused shakes for a uniquely Caribbean twist.

Try

• Classic vanilla shake

• Rum milkshake

• Homemade waffle cone

• Chocolate malt

Best For

• Families

• Beach days

• Dessert after Magens Bay

3. Sunny Days Ice Cream — Best Family Ice Cream Shop

Sunny Days Ice Cream Web Address: 6100 Red Hook Quarters C2-5, Saint.Thomas, St Thomas 00802, U.S. Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-690-3648

Situated in Red Hook, Sunny Days is an excellent stop after dinner or before heading back from a day on the water.

With dozens of flavors, sundaes, brownies, milkshakes, and custom ice cream cakes, there's something for everyone. Custom cakes are also available for birthdays and celebrations.

Signature Items

• Oreo ice cream cake

• Brownie sundaes

• Tropical flavors

• Milkshakes

4. Virgin Islands Ice Cream Company — Best Homemade Waffle Cones

Virgin Islands Ice Cream Company Web Address: 37 Main Street Inside AH Riise Mall, St Thomas 00802, US Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-998-8095

Hidden inside A.H. Riise Mall in downtown Charlotte Amalie, this charming shop is known for its freshly made waffle cones and tropical-inspired flavors.

It's an easy stop while shopping along Main Street and one of the island's most underrated dessert destinations.

Don't Miss

• Fresh waffle cones

• Mango ice cream

• Coconut flavors

• Vegan-friendly selections

5. DizziBrands — Best Adult Dessert

DizziBrands Web Address: 25-A Dronningens Gade, St Thomas, VI 00802 Phone: +13402273111

Looking for something a little different?

DizziBrands specializes in alcohol-infused ice cream, frozen pops, and dessert treats made specifically for adults (21+).

Popular flavors incorporate vodka, rum, tequila, and other spirits into creamy frozen desserts.

Best For

• Couples

• Bar hopping

• Downtown Charlotte Amalie

• Adults looking for a unique dessert

6. Creamy Crepes — Best Dessert Creations

Creamy Crepes Web Address: St. Thomas, 6200 Smith Bay Rd Ste 1A, Charlotte Amalie, St Thomas 00802, U.S. Virgin Islands Phone: +1 786-890-2527

Sometimes one dessert isn't enough.

Creamy Crepes combines made-to-order crepes with ice cream, Nutella, fresh fruit, whipped cream, and warm waffle cones.

Located in Red Hook, it's one of the island's newest sweet spots.

Try

• Nutella & banana crepe

• Ice cream waffle cone

• Milkshakes

• Custom dessert combinations

7. Calypso Cafe — Best Hidden Gem

Calypso Cafe Web Address: Inside AH Riise, 37 Main St, Mall, St Thomas 00802, U.S. Virgin Islands Phone: +1 340-998-8095

Most visitors discover Calypso Cafe for the coffee—but stay for the ice cream.

Tucked inside A.H. Riise Mall, it's a quiet place to cool off after exploring Charlotte Amalie's historic streets.

Best Ice Cream by Category

Best Gelato

• Scoops & Brew

• Creamy Crepes

Best Milkshakes

• Udder Delights Ice Cream Parlor

• Sunny Days Ice Cream

Best Homemade Waffle Cones

• Virgin Islands Ice Cream Company

• Creamy Crepes

Best Tropical Flavors

Look for Caribbean-inspired flavors like:

• Mango

• Coconut

• Passion fruit

• Guava

• Piña colada

• Rum raisin

You'll commonly find these at:

• Scoops & Brew

• Virgin Islands Ice Cream Company

• Sunny Days Ice Cream

Best Ice Cream After the Beach

After spending the day in the sun, these stops are especially convenient:

After Magens Bay

• Udder Delights Ice Cream Parlor

After Water Island

• Scoops & Brew

After Sapphire Beach

• Sunny Days Ice Cream

• The Beach Buzz

Best Family-Friendly Ice Cream

Families with kids will enjoy:

• Sunny Days Ice Cream

• Scoops & Brew

• Udder Delights Ice Cream Parlor

Best Adult Desserts

For visitors looking for something beyond a traditional scoop:

• DizziBrands

• Udder Delights Ice Cream Parlor (rum milkshakes)

Best Ice Cream Near the Cruise Port

If you're arriving in Havensight or Crown Bay:

• Scoops & Brew

• Calypso Cafe

• Virgin Islands Ice Cream Company

Best Ice Cream Near Red Hook

• Sunny Days Ice Cream

• Creamy Crepes

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the best overall ice cream shop in St. Thomas?

Scoops & Brew consistently ranks among the island's favorites thanks to its handcrafted gelato, coffee, and marina location. (Tripadvisor)

Where can I find homemade waffle cones?

Virgin Islands Ice Cream Company and Creamy Crepes are both known for fresh-made waffle cones.

Which shop is best after visiting Magens Bay?

Udder Delights Ice Cream Parlor is just minutes away and is famous for its creamy milkshakes.

Are there alcohol-infused desserts?

Yes. DizziBrands specializes in liquor-infused ice cream and frozen treats for guests 21 and older.