Charter boats anchored with inflatable loungers in turquoise water

Christmas Cove, St. Thomas: Snorkeling, Turtles & Pizza Pi

November 20, 2026

Christmas Cove is a sheltered bay on the west side of Great St. James, a small island off the east end of St. Thomas in the U.S. Virgin Islands. It is known for easy snorkeling over coral heads and sea grass where sea turtles feed, and for Pizza Pi, a pizzeria that floats in the cove. There is no road or ferry service, so you can only get there by boat.

Where Christmas Cove Is

Great St. James sits in Pillsbury Sound, the stretch of water between St. Thomas and St. John. Christmas Cove is tucked behind the island on its St. Thomas side, about two miles from Red Hook. That puts it close to the marinas on the east end, including Sapphire Beach Resort & Marina in Smith Bay, a short drive from Red Hook.

The cove is part of the St. Thomas East End Reserves (STEER), a multi-use marine protected area managed by the USVI Department of Planning and Natural Resources (DPNR). STEER includes the Great St. James marine reserve and wildlife sanctuary, so treat the reef and sea grass as protected habitat and check DPNR for current rules before you go.

How to Get There

Christmas Cove has no ferry stop, no dock for visitors and no road access. Your options are:

  • Group snorkel tours. Several sailing and powercat snorkel tours stop at the cove, some paired with a Pizza Pi visit.
  • Your own boat or a bareboat rental. The cove is a common overnight stop for boaters staying in the USVI, and moorings are available (see etiquette below).
  • A private charter. A captained boat lets you choose how long to stay, when to swim and what to pair it with. From the east end, Christmas Cove fits easily into a half-day boat charter.

Snorkeling at Christmas Cove

The cove has a sand and coral-patch bottom in roughly 4 to 12 meters (13 to 40 feet) of water, with coral heads along its edges. Snorkelers often see reef fish over the coral and sea turtles grazing over the grass beds. One local charter blog quotes a guest who saw close to 10 turtles in an hour or two of snorkeling, though sightings are never guaranteed. Stingrays are also reported here.

Fish reported in the cove include parrotfish, blue tang and angelfish, along with starfish and conch on the bottom. The water is generally sheltered, which makes it a good choice for families and newer snorkelers. For more spots around the island, see our St. Thomas snorkeling guide.

Snorkel tips for the cove

  • Stay off the coral. Do not stand on, kick or touch coral heads; fin gently near the edges where they grow.
  • Use reef-safe sunscreen, or cover up with a rash guard.
  • Watch for boat traffic. The cove gets busy and boat wakes come through, so stay close to your boat and consider a bright swim cap or float.
  • Ask your captain where the coral heads and grass beds are that day, and where boats are moving.

Sea Turtles: Watch, Don't Touch

Turtles in the cove are wild, protected animals. NOAA Fisheries asks snorkelers not to touch, chase or feed sea turtles and to give them plenty of room (its guideline is 50 yards). Sea turtles in U.S. waters are protected under the Endangered Species Act. Give them plenty of room, let them surface to breathe without being crowded, and never block a turtle's path. If you want to know which species you might meet and how to tell them apart, read the complete guide to sea turtles in St. Thomas.

Pizza Pi, the Floating Pizzeria

Pizza Pi is a pizzeria built on a boat and anchored in Christmas Cove. It has been part of the cove since the mid-2010s and its own website, current for 2026, still lists it as floating in Christmas Cove. Ownership has changed hands over the years; the current owners took over in 2023.

How it works: boats pull up nearby, guests order and collect their pizza from the pickup window, and dinghy drive-thru service is offered. The business describes itself as "swim up, raft up." Pizza Pi runs on a season, and hours change, so check its website or social pages for current days and how to order before you plan lunch around it.

Because lunch is not included on private charters, Pizza Pi is a handy way to eat without leaving the water.

Mooring and Anchoring Etiquette

Christmas Cove has mooring buoys, and it is a popular stop, especially in peak season. A few rules of thumb:

  1. Use a mooring if one is free. Moorings protect the bottom from anchor damage. Moorings here are fee-based and fill up, so arrive early, and check DPNR for current rules and fees in STEER.
  2. If you must anchor, drop on sand only. Anchoring is only allowed where sea grass and coral are not present.
  3. Go slow. Enter and leave at idle speed. Swimmers and turtles share the water with boats, and wakes roll through the cove.
  4. Give other boats room. Leave space for swing, and do not tie up to a mooring that is already in use.
  5. Keep noise and trash on board. Pack out everything you bring.

On a captained charter, your captain handles the mooring and boat positioning, so you can focus on the water.

Tips for Your Visit

  • Plan to stay on the water. Your food option here is Pizza Pi, not a beach bar, so bring snacks and drinks if it is closed.
  • Bring a cover-up, hat, sunglasses and plenty of water. Our St. Thomas packing list covers the rest.
  • If you want a quieter swim, ask your captain to time the stop around tour boat traffic.

Best Time to Visit

Conditions matter more than the calendar here. The cove is sheltered, but it gets busy, especially in peak season, and moorings go early. If eating at Pizza Pi is part of the plan, confirm it is open for the season first. Weather and wind decide how comfortable any anchorage is on a given day, and a licensed captain will check conditions before heading out.

Nearby Stops to Combine

Because the cove sits in Pillsbury Sound, it pairs well with other east-end and St. John stops on the same day:

Christmas Cove FAQ

Can you get to Christmas Cove without a boat?

No. There is no ferry or road access. You need to go on a tour, your own boat or a private charter.

Are there sea turtles at Christmas Cove?

Turtles are regularly seen feeding over the sea grass in the cove, but they are wild animals and sightings are not guaranteed. Watch from a distance and do not touch or feed them.

Is Pizza Pi still open?

Pizza Pi's website, current for 2026, lists it as floating in Christmas Cove. It operates seasonally with changing hours, so check its website or social media before you go.

Is Christmas Cove good for beginner snorkelers?

The cove is sheltered and has shallow coral heads and grass beds, which suits many beginners. Boat traffic is the main thing to watch, so stay near your boat and follow your captain's guidance.

Is Christmas Cove a protected area?

Yes. It is part of the St. Thomas East End Reserves, a marine protected area managed by DPNR. Check DPNR for current rules.

How long should I spend at Christmas Cove?

There is no set time. A snorkel stop plus lunch fits comfortably in a half-day charter, and on a private charter you set the pace.

Visit by Private Boat

Phoenix Island Charters runs private, captained day charters, mostly from Sapphire Beach Resort & Marina on the east end of St. Thomas. There is no set itinerary, so your captain can build the day around Christmas Cove, turtles and lunch on the water. Half-day trips run 9:00 to 12:30 or 1:00 to 4:30, and full USVI days run 9:00 to 4:00.

Every charter includes a USCG-licensed captain, safety gear, snorkel gear (masks, fins and sanitized snorkels), inflatable loungers, bottled water, a cooler with ice, a bathroom and shade. BYOB is welcome; lunch is not included. For smaller groups, Phoenix (Mainship Pilot 30, up to 6 guests, fuel included) is built for USVI days like this one. Compare all boats on our fleet page or see charter options.

Check availability and book your Christmas Cove charter.

Back to Blog

Phoenix Island Charters

Your private day on the water.

+1 (727) 249-7295 · [email protected]

FIND US
Sapphire Beach Resort & Marina • Slip 29
6720 Estate Smith Bay Road • St. Thomas, USVI 00802
Get directions ↗

Our Fleet · Charter Options · Captain’s Compass · Contact Us · Upload Passports

Read our Tripadvisor reviews ↗ · Read our Google reviews ↗

© 2026 Phoenix Island Charters    Terms & Conditions

Phoenix Charters Virgin Islands
Tripadvisor — read Phoenix Island Charters reviews